CSRC — Journal


2026-10-26 · Prop 65 · Stephen Schnack · 5 min read

Cadmium and Prop 65: the quieter sibling of lead

In short: unlike mercury, cadmium comes with a number you can check. OEHHA’s reproductive-toxicity safe harbor level for oral exposure to cadmium is 4.1 micrograms per day, so the compliance arithmetic is the same as for lead: concentration times serving size, compared against a fixed figure. The catch is that cadmium rides along in foods people eat in volume, cocoa and leafy greens above all, so the serving size does most of the work.

Our mercury post was about a chemical with no safe harbor number. Cadmium is the contrast case: listed, quantified, and still easy to overlook next to lead.

Two listings, one oral number

California listed cadmium as a developmental toxicant and a male reproductive toxicant on May 1, 1997. It is also listed as a carcinogen as “cadmium and cadmium compounds.” The numbers that matter for food and supplements come from the reproductive listings: OEHHA’s cadmium page shows a maximum allowable dose level (MADL) of 4.1 micrograms per day for the oral route.

The cancer figure on that page, a no significant risk level of 0.05 micrograms per day, is for inhalation. Neither the chemical page nor OEHHA’s safe harbor list shows an oral cancer level, so for something you swallow, the 4.1 figure is the one in the table. The list also notes that when exposure comes by more than one route, total exposure has to be considered.

The serving math

The arithmetic is short enough to do at the kitchen table. Micrograms per day equals micrograms of cadmium per gram of product, times grams eaten per day.

Take a hypothetical product testing at 0.1 parts per million cadmium (0.1 micrograms per gram). One 28-gram serving delivers 0.1 × 28 = 2.8 micrograms, which is 68 percent of 4.1. Two servings a day would be 5.6 micrograms, or 137 percent. Same product, same label, different answer, depending only on how much is eaten. Exposure from the rest of the diet counts toward the same number; a single product’s share is only part of the picture.

Compare lead, where the MADL is 0.5 micrograms per day. Cadmium’s figure is about eight times larger, which is why a result that would be alarming for lead can look unremarkable for cadmium. It is also why serving size matters more here: foods eaten by the handful can approach 4.1 in a way that a trace additive cannot.

Where cadmium comes from

Cadmium occurs in soil naturally and is added by phosphate fertilizers and industrial deposition. Plants take it up through the roots, and some crops take up more than others. Cocoa, leafy greens, rice and root vegetables are the usual suspects, which is the same list we gave in our protein powder piece. A flavoring or an ingredient from one of those crops carries cadmium into a finished product however the product is marketed.

What the public record shows about chocolate

Consumer Reports tested 28 dark chocolate bars in 2022 and reported cadmium and lead in all of them; for 23, an ounce a day would put an adult over a level it says may be harmful for at least one of the two metals. Its 2023 update covered 48 products, 16 of them above its levels for at least one metal. The National Confectioners Association’s response was that chocolate is safe to eat, that OEHHA’s levels are not food safety standards, and that a Proposition 65 settlement set its own concentration levels for cocoa and chocolate products.

We report that as public record, not as our finding. The useful point is structural: the same product can be compared against more than one yardstick, and the yardsticks answer different questions.

What a result does and does not mean

A cadmium result near or above a fraction of 4.1 micrograms per day for a serving is a threshold comparison, nothing more. It does not say anyone was harmed, and it does not by itself say a warning was required: the statute has its own exemptions, and the full analysis depends on the exposure assessment, not on one lab number. A result well below the line is also only a data point for that lot.

The takeaway

When CSRC reports cadmium, it will publish the concentration, the serving size, the arithmetic, and the comparison to 4.1 micrograms per day, with the result expressed as a percentage of the threshold. The number is checkable. The work is in showing it.


This article is educational information about California law and regulatory toxicology, not legal or medical advice. Regulatory descriptions are summaries; OEHHA's regulations control. © 2026 Consumer Safety Research Center Inc.

← Journal Report a product