CSRC — Journal


2026-11-16 · Prop 65 · Stephen Schnack · 5 min read

When the store is responsible for a Prop 65 warning

In short: Proposition 65’s warning duty sits first with the businesses that make and move a product: the manufacturer, producer, packager, importer, supplier or distributor. California’s warning regulation makes the retail seller responsible for a consumer product warning only in five listed circumstances, such as when the product is the store’s own brand, or when the store was handed warning materials and did not display them. Outside that list, the store’s job is to pass along the warnings it receives.

Readers ask why a Proposition 65 notice sometimes goes to the store as well as the brand. The answer is in one section of the regulations, and it is short enough to read in full.

The rule starts with the maker

The statute’s warning requirement is one sentence. As quoted in the California Attorney General’s Proposition 65 FAQ: “No person in the course of doing business shall knowingly and intentionally expose any individual to a chemical known to the state to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity without first giving a clear and reasonable warning.” The same page lists the exemptions, including one for businesses with nine or fewer employees.

That sentence does not say which business in a supply chain has to give the warning. The regulation does. Section 25600.2 of Title 27, titled “Responsibility to Provide Consumer Product Exposure Warnings,” opens by noting that the Act requires OEHHA to minimize the burden on retail sellers “to the extent practicable,” except where the retail seller itself is responsible for introducing a listed chemical into the product.

Two ways the supply chain can comply

Under subsection (b), a manufacturer, producer, packager, importer, supplier or distributor has two options. It can put a compliant warning on the product label or labeling. Or it can send a written notice to the authorized agent of the business it sells to, or of the retail seller. That notice has to say the product may result in an exposure to one or more listed chemicals, identify the product (a Universal Product Code is one example the regulation gives), and include all the necessary warning materials: labels, shelf signs or tags, and warning language for products sold on the internet. The notice has to be renewed annually while the product is sold in California.

Subsection (d) then gives the retail seller its ordinary job: placement and maintenance of the warning materials it receives, including warnings for products sold over the internet.

The five circumstances

Subsection (e) says the retail seller is responsible for providing the warning “only when one or more of the following circumstances exist.” Paraphrased:

  1. Its own brand. The retail seller sells the product under a brand or trademark it, or an affiliated entity, owns or licenses.
  2. It added the chemical. The retail seller knowingly introduced a listed chemical into the product, or knowingly caused one to be created in it.
  3. It hid the label. The retail seller covered, obscured or altered a warning label that the supply chain had affixed.
  4. It received the materials and did not use them. The retail seller got the notice and warning materials and sold the product without conspicuously posting or displaying the warning.
  5. It knew, and no one upstream is reachable. The retail seller has actual knowledge of the potential exposure requiring the warning, and there is no manufacturer, producer, packager, importer, supplier or distributor who both is a “person in the course of doing business” under the Act and has a designated agent for service of process in California or a place of business in California.

The fifth item has two halves, and both must be true. Knowledge alone is not enough under that paragraph if a business upstream is covered by the Act and can be reached in California.

What “actual knowledge” means

Subsection (f) defines the term for the fifth circumstance. The retail seller has actual knowledge when it receives information from any reliable source that allows it to identify the specific product or products that cause the exposure. The knowledge has to reach the retail seller, its authorized agent, or a person whose knowledge can be imputed to the retail seller.

There is a timing rule as well. If the source of the knowledge is a 60-day notice, the retail seller is not deemed to have actual knowledge of the alleged exposure until five business days after it receives the notice, and the notice has to describe the product specifically enough for the retail seller to readily identify it.

What a retailer has to hand over

Subsection (g) creates a separate duty that has nothing to do with fault. On written request, a retail seller must promptly provide the name and contact information of the product’s manufacturer, producer, packager, importer, supplier and distributor, to the extent that information is reasonably available to it. The request can come from OEHHA, from the Attorney General or a district or city attorney with authority to enforce the Act, or from a person who has served a 60-day notice about the product.

Finally, subsection (i) lets the businesses sort it out among themselves. A supplier and the business it sells to may sign a written agreement allocating responsibility for the warning, and that agreement supersedes subsections (b) through (e), provided the consumer still receives a compliant warning before exposure.

Why notices list more than one business

The Attorney General’s FAQ describes the enforcement mechanics: a private party may sue only after giving at least 60 days’ notice to the business, the Attorney General and the appropriate district attorney and city attorney, and only if none of those public enforcers has taken action. A court can order a violation stopped, and civil penalties run up to $2,500 per day for each violation.

Which businesses belong in a notice follows from the list above. A product sold under a store’s own label, a warning sign that arrived and was never posted, an overseas maker with no California presence: each of these points to a different paragraph of subsection (e). Our methodology post describes the notice step; this section of the regulations is what determines who the recipients can be.

A draft change to watch

In July 2026, OEHHA circulated proposed draft regulatory text for a pre-regulatory public workshop dated July 30, 2026. Two of its topics touch this section: “Clarifying when warnings are required for internet purchases,” which cites section 25600.2(b), and “Simplifying language regarding retailers’ responsibility to give manufacturer warnings to the public,” which cites section 25600.2(e).

These are workshop drafts, not adopted regulations. The current text controls until a rulemaking is finished, and we will report on the wording if and when OEHHA formally proposes it.

The takeaway

The store is not the default. The regulation names the supply chain first and the retail seller only in five listed situations. Reading a notice against that list is the way to understand why a particular business is on it.


This article is educational information about California law and regulation, not legal or medical advice. Regulatory descriptions are summaries; the statute and OEHHA's regulations control. © 2026 Consumer Safety Research Center Inc.

← Journal Report a product